With income inequality rising, the middle class increasingly squeezed and more of us than ever feeling the pinch, why hasn't the American public risen up to demand reform? It's happened before, as in the Progressive Era, during the New Deal and the Great Society, so why not now?
In his latest "Regulators" vlog, University of California Economics professor and former Secretary of Labor Robert Reich explains the three reasons keeping Americans from rising up in open rebellion to demand change.
Support The Point for FREE by doing your Amazon shopping through this link (bookmark it!) http://www.amazon.com/?tag=townsquaretyt-20
The reason the lower and middle class do not rise up and because they are mesmerized/ hypnotized/ and zombied out by TELEVISION. There will be no revolution because there is an escape from it all -- TV. The obstacle to change is TV. Why is it people don't care ??? Cable TV is like a never ending CIA brain washing experiment that never stops working and never ends. It's freaky. Look at the POTUS and his words and actions; never has someone gotten away with sooo much. People don't care. TV is the drug of indifference ! What else could it be ???? Id like to know how 300 million americans suddenly don't care about anything.
A major reason why Americans are not rebelling is because of movies, tv shows, video games, and so forth. People are having their needs met by generic and synthetic experiences instead of the real deal. So people are bound by a addictive pattern of seeking empty means of fulfillment instead of seeking things with substance, depth, and worth.
The jews (communists) recently shared $16,000,000,000,000 with their jewish foreign cousins:
Tax money that should have gone to our infrastructure.
All I ever hear and see are the issues. We know what the problems are. Where are the solutions? I have one and it's huge and will take someone like you to help pull it off. It's quite brilliant and doesn't involve protesting. This is a plan that will get to the heart of the problem and force change! I would like to talk about this with you, but I noticed no where is there any contact info. Just a lot of selling and talking so far.
Two sides to every story, including this one. The problem with this country is lack of a fair middle: slackers who refuse to work and workers who refuse to slack. The attitude is, "I'm afraid someone's going to take my job," or "I'm too good to take that job." The answers are in the Bible beginning with, "he who won't work, neither will he eat."
You know Robert I usually have great respect for you however it's become quite clear that you are a communist and that you do not have the best interest of this country in mind you would like to turn it into a socialist nightmare. Now since we all know that socialism is a failed ideology I just can't understand why a person of your education would even entertain the thought. Finally why would we have a revolution when our system is working the way it has evolved to be?
Working people need to take back the liberals from the Clinton/Reich globalist loons and realize pushing immigration is their primary weapon against you. The old left opposed immigration because that was obvious to them. These globalist jokers are taking you for a ride. Why do you think the workers are terrified? Why do you think college costs so much? These are both primarily, almost exclusively, due to immigration.
There is but only one factor for the lack thereof, that being the circumstances are completely different now than from the late 19th to early 20th centuries which had various labour strikes and wars in response to low wages and dire working conditions that came with coal mining. You still see strikes today in other occupations, but there is not a nationwide culmination of strikes because there is not a nationwide industry network of system abuse that all Americans can relate to, so other than someone hating their job, there really isn't much for Americans to unite on to even start a revolution for. Today working conditions and worker's rights in coal mining have greatly increased, but if it gets anywhere near as bad as it was in the 1930s all over the country, surely you'd start to see the forming new labour unions and more potentially violent strikes by coal miners.
Boycott ALL shopping except necessities. Shut down the consumer economy. There's not a thing they can do. We keep shopping, buying Chinese crap, like good little consumers, and overeating. Get off your f*cking phone. Drop your cable. If necessary, hold your taxes. Guns won't work, but non-cooperation will. Time to take our support away from corporations, and big banks, go local credit union. Don't invest in their worthless paper.
Robert, tell us what your annual income is, how much your home is worth, do you receive any income from sitting on corp board(s), what is your annual income from speaking engagements? Do you go on vacations? Do you have health insurance? If you have children are they in college, going to go to college, or graduated from college. If you have children are they employed, and give us some idea as to how much they make per year? Do your children have loans to pay for their educations? Did your children go to public schools? How many days per month do you go out for meals? What grocery stores do you or your family shop at? Do you eat organic foods? Do you have domestic help to clean your home, or tend to your yard? When you travel to your speaking engagements do you book your own reservations? We know you travel first class. Do you have a vacation home(s)? It's pretty hard to take you seriously, when you obviously enjoy cake.
" A nation of sheep will beget a govt. of wolves "
~ Edward R. Murrow
" Democracy is two wolves and a lamb voting on what to have for lunch;
LIBERTY is a well armed lamb contesting the vote "
~ Ben Franklin
" It is dangerous to be right in matters on which the established authorities are wrong "
" If there are degrees of evil, it is hard to say who is more contemptible :
The brute who assumes the right to force the mind of others or the moral degenerate who grants to others the right to force his/her mind "
" The smallest minority on earth is the individual.
Those who deny individual rights cannot claim to be defenders of minorities "
" We are fast approaching the stage of the ultimate inversion :
the stage where the govt. is free to do anything it pleases, while the citizens may act only by permission;
which is the stage of the darkest periods of human history, the stage of rule by BRUTE FORCE "
~ Ayn Rand
I'm sorry to all, however we should have had " the latter " a LOOOOONNNNGGG time ago...IMO
An angry, intelligent, well armed populace who united (no matter the race!) against all corruption & evil power is the only thing these folks are terrified of!
You know why ??
Because we'd squash them like the roaches they are & they know it!
Why do you think G. soros is funding these racist groups?
Divide & Conquer baby.
*** WAKE UP AMERICANS ***
And then you look at Flint, Michigan. 18 months these citizens have sat idly by in council meetings "demanding" change. For 18 months now their children have been poisoned. It's time to wake up from the sandmans dream people... wake up...
"Fewer than 20% of Americans trust our government today" SO WHY DO WE LET THEM KEEP DOING THINGS LIKE FLINT MICHIGAN?
It's time to stop "demanding" justice and TAKE justice.
" WHY DO WE LET THEM KEEP DOING THINGS"
Because of our unhealthy relationship with government, and the the exception status that we issue said entity.
ANY other organization that failed that often, that deeply and purchased through its actions and behaviors the degree of dissatisfaction and mistrust with its supposed customer/serving base, would be dissolved, investigated and criminally charged BY government.
Government means never having your repeated and monumental failures used to question the validity of your authority, presence or existence.
Modern western government is granted an unlimited free-pass for failure, overreach and the breach of standards that IT ITSELF is supposed to be present to enforce.
Its established a relationship within the lives of western people, that said people wont extend and/or issue to their own family members and loved ones.
I'm canadian and I'm surprised that america hasn't revolted yet. It's getting worse and worse every passing months over there and people don't seem to want to change shit.
They need to wake up quick because revolution within the next decade or 2 is IMMINENT in my opinion.
Don't let them take your guns... you're probably going to need them... A LOT.
The minimum wage varies from state to state and in some, it can be as high as $10 - 11 per hour; also wages vary per occupation. No one is going to earn a lot of money working at fast foods. Higher wages are determined by a higher level of education and experience as well, so there really is no pretext for a nationwide revolution in America, so unless you think that McDonald's employees all across Georgia are going to go on an armed strike, you're delusional.
Far from unacceptable??? Dude, 7,25 bucks an hour in america compared to 11,25 bucks an hour here in my province of Quebec in Canada.
Wages in America ARE unacceptable. And progressive era? The people may be progressive... But the government running the USA obviously isn't.
It's not particularly surprising since the right has no real desire nor reason to revolt against the upper class, though there has been some upheaval by the left in the form of heated protests, working conditions and wages in America are far from unacceptable in comparison to it's state of being in the progressive era.
great vid! here are a couple other reasons... 4. divide and conquer: big media is turning the people against each other. the neo-cons are too busy yelling at the libs and vice-verse when we should all be yelling at the gov. 5. bread and circuses: junk food is cheap and we're fixated on consumerism. people turn violent against each other while waiting for the next iphone but will barely pay attention while the militarized police goes open season on american citizens on american soil.
This does not explain why things are what they are, it only lists the symptoms. I guess it's impossible to do that in 3 minutes. Take students for example. Higher education in the US used to be almost free, and now its costs are exorbitant and student debt astonishingly exceeds credit card debt. How did that came about? In places like Mexico and France any attempts at making education paid faced mass student protest who successively fought back. What did american students do? Just swallowed the bitter pill and went to apply for more loan. Why was that so?
+Alexander Shaduri Also, the fact that every time I visit a college campus---ANY campus---what are the students doing? They're staring at their FUCKING PHONES ALL DAY. That's one thing you don't hear a lot about. Why have a physical address when they can do just about EVERYTHING on their goddamned phones? There is another thing people don't like to hear, and that is that Americans really don't WANT to revolt. Americans have this tendency to bitch and gripe and carry on about how much they hate their jobs and their lives and everything else. But they would rather drink, smoke cigarettes/meth/crack, show off their new ride/vape mod/tats/piercings/hair color, or stare at fucking video games for hours on end than make an effort to force radical change. I don''t believe Americans will EVER revolt. They LOVE drama and manufactured crises, not to mention Black Fridays, and they don't EVER want to give those things up. Americans would rather die than revolt.
I'm in agreement with Mr. Reich, but I wonder...if so many Americans are barely getting by and living paycheck to paycheck, how do we explain "Black Friday" and the subsequent holiday spending insanity? Don't most middle class Americans still have disposable cash? Or are people just putting themselves deeper in debt via credit card?
I'm sorry, but can you not see that those very policies you claim were so wonderful were very much part of the cause of the problems, even recently? Hell, why not suggest bringing back the NRA (recovery act) and let the largest corporations set prices again. When was American EVER a democracy? How can anyone listen to someone some fundamentally and inherently wrong from the very premise of his argument? This guy is just another trap to circle you back into the system with flowery rhetoric and pseudo-intellectual doube-speak.
Truism: When you have nothing, you have nothing, you have nothing to lose, so revolution doesn't seem so bad.
But when you have ANYTHING, you then have EVERYTHING to lose, and revolution doesn't look so appealing.
The genius of the "Murkin System" ro now has been that it has provided nearly everybody--the majority, so far, at least--with SOMETHING to lose.
All the "progressive" movements did was increase the number of poor people and help them identify them Democratic party as their only hope. They are the destroyers of middle class values...without them there will be no middle class. Just rulers and followers which is exactly what they want. Immoral people do not produce moral results. People who perceive themselves as "saviors" do not seek "equals" around them. Grow up children.
Well stated "Demoncrats are the destroyers of middle class values...without values there will be no middle class. Just rulers and followers which is exactly what they want. Immoral people do not produce moral results! (aka: Clintons, Podesta, Watters, Pelosi, Feinstein, Shumer, McCain, Cummings, Obama, Wasserman-Shultz, et al!
The main problem is that people have fallen for the both parties are the same game that the right has pushed which is a brash lie, 19 million people have healthcare to day thanks to the democrat party , would be more if GOP was not fighting it in GOP controlled states. that is the largest major move to boost lower and middle income in a decade and taxes have been raised on top income to pay for it and that is why GOP are fighting it so hard and working so hard to convince people that voting for democrats will not help them so that they can take that away .
It will have to get much worse before Americans act and things improve for the general populace. Until poverty, unemployment and hunger become more common. Revolution will sweep the country. If it gets really bad before political and social reforms happen, then it will be like the French revolution and political leaders, bankers, and the uber wealthy will get it in the neck like the French aristocracy did. Armed revolution is possible because thanks to the NRA there are an abundance of firearms in this country. The problem is that if that scenario occurs, what could replace our current government could be much much worse. You will have our current leaders and the American people's indifferent attitude to thank for that. Speak out and VOTE!
People rising up for the progressive era? lol Please are you kidding me? Most people have studied history, we have seen the epic failures of the new deal programs. High unemployment from 1932 to 1939 and huge deficits. The students loan problem is just like the housing problem. The President should be asking for people to take personal responsibility. Many people select a degree with nothing in common with the skills needed for today's jobs. Many people are happy receiving their government cheese! This may be the real reason they do not care.
Taxes stayed really high throughout the Eisenhower years. That's what you guys don't want us to believe. We've had low taxes on the rich for the last 30 years under the promise that it would trickle down, but all the working and middle class has received is a golden shower courtesy of St. Ronnie.
the reason there is no revolt, is because americans hate Communism/fascism.. if you study revolutions, you will know that communism always win in the end...
revolution is what the enemy of the United States of America wants.
live free and with the truth
+Hand OverFist my question is; what makes you think it's your "country"? It's a piece of earth given a label. What makes you think it's yours? Did the higher power give you exclusive rights to that piece of land? No. Human did. It was the human that conditioned your mind. It is the human that divides us. "Race" "nationality" does not exist. & that's a revelation for a lot of people.
Hand overfist whites come to american spend 400 years killing indigenous people and stealing their land, forcing them into southern desert. Then tell those descendants starving in the desert they are illegal in their native territory, and we arent racist...
Nazis sounded less racist, at least jews really were immigrants to germany, unlike mexicans to america.
It's not racist to not want millions of people storming into your country when we cant even take care of our own, that's just damn foolish!
The mex govt is JUST as guilty as the obama administration, same goes for the drug cartels and the millions of Americans using the drugs they bring across!
Stop obsessing over race & see the bigger picture, this is NOT just about illegal immigration!
This is a VERY COMPLICATED, COMPLEX problem as I'm sure you're aware.
My family being MexAme. LOVE this country & don't want to see it fall ( unlike so many leftist types )
We have our problems,, yes and this is still the BEST country on the planet!
Every empire rises and falls. We are just seeing the beginning of our fall. Nothing last's forever, not even the good old U.S.A. Im just hoping I don't get to see the fall of liberty within my own lifetime. Freedom and Democracy is hard to maintain. It takes a lifetime to build, but only moments to destroy. Take it in! This is what greed does it destroys everything. There is a saying! For evil to triumph, is for good men to do nothing, or give me liberty or give me death. If there is anything worth fighting for, it's this. Because, your not going to like the alternative, that I can promise you.
It's hard to disagree with your basic premise. Our saving grace will be that the 1% won't know when to quit, they'll just keep taking and taking until revolution is unavoidable. How long will it take though? The US is already beginning to wane in the world economy, we have 50 good years left (at best). We are also leading the formation of Global Climate change. Iran, China, India and Russia to some extent will be dominant by then. We need to claim our government back in time to make some friends on the world stage. A great start would be to mobilize voters in Tea Party districts.
People don't want to revolt because that gov't liberals love so much uses threats of violence to keep ppl compliant. I'd like to revolt against paying the pentagon, but I'd be kidnapped and thrown in a cage.
This is one of the most amazing videos on the state of public feeling towards wealth inequality, activism and reform I've ever seen. The people are fearful of losing what little they have, and getting saddled with growing debt, not seeing that activism and reform are exactly the means by which they can get more of their share as a whole. Courage by way of activism will lead to reform, despite the fear ~ the only alternative is delay until violent revolution, which is means worth struggling to avoid.
I believe you are wrong in your assessment.
America has already had two failed peoples revolts in recent history, the first was the Tea Party, and the second was OWS. Currently America is having mini revolts, but to get the big revolt a catalyst has to happen. Something to trigger the enough is enough effect in the population along with a charismatic leader or group that sum up the changes wanted.
The Tea party failed because it had the wrong leadership directing the movement down the wrong paths, and OWS failed because it refused to be a group so let the status quo leadership continue unchanged. But both showed there was discontent brewing.
Currently you have a third revolution starting up, the one for minimum wages, which is in the glowing ember phase, it would only require a catalyst event against the protesters to blow the embers into a flame and grab the publics enough is enough feelings.
Lets not forget the other two reasons the corporate take over of the media and the extreme classification of almost any information that would reveal the crimes of our government. I think what has slipped out so far is only the tip of the iceberg.
Plus, I really hate how our space program has been mostly removed from the public into sercret corporate/military hands, I believe the us space program creates hope for the future and of course lots of spin off technological developments. We have lots of potential beneficial technology that could change our society, yet it's held back for the benefit of corporate profits. greed is holding us back
The reason is the metaphor of the poor frog being boiled alive with a slight twist....the elite are controlling the heat to just the right temperature so the poor little froggys can not only be boiled but also tenderized. This way the elite can pick us to pieces right down to our bones.......They have been doing this for thousands of years, one day the poor little froggys will wake up....maybe!
This guys an idiot. Germany had a violent uprising during its worst economic period, they put the fucking Nazis in power. He's right that a storm is coming but its not like all the uneducated, paranoid, racist, gun toting conspiracy theorists are going to usher in an era of peace and liberty, what comes after will be far worse than what there is now.
You forgot reason #4: The rich have bought out and taken over the Jesus franchise so today Jesus belongs to the rich. Go to any evangelical church and see what I mean. To be a good Christian they teach you must vote conservative which is the same as supporting the rich at the expense of everyone else.
Well there has been many heated protests in response to the corporate influence and wealth, by the left. The reason you are not seeing a revolution has to do with a political party's perception. The Right is very pro wealthy, so of course you are not going to see them engage in an open revolt in response. They are however rebelling against the government in other disputes such as Federal land management.
I’m not as sanguine as Reich about future reforms… Especially not when there seems to be an extraordinary number of people out there who regard any discussion of wealth inequality as nothing but “class warfare” fomented by “socialists” and/or disgruntled/resentful/envious “losers” and “deadbeats”… Ironically, many of the same people who think this way are themselves poor or just living paycheck to paycheck, perhaps one medical mishap away from total catastrophe.
Look at all the revolutions going on around the world; did they happen when things just started falling apart for the country? No, they happened when the country completely fell apart, and conditions became so unacceptable that the people had to rise up. Sadly America is going down the same route; only when conditions are unlivable will anything change.
I can see how the 3 reasons stated would hinder ONE type of revolution... But honestly and saddly the real reason is that most people are easily pacified with celebrity bs. Society has systematically ostracized anyone that doesn't play social games. We are all slaves to the politics we profess to abhore. The Venus Project got tied to Occupy which got tied to feminism. Revolution just isn't trendy anymore. Fucking hipster BS. Psyops laugh at you.
yea my bad it gets rather confusing as their work was all based on Gustov Le bons theory's ... they merrily turned his work into an applied science that is shockingly effective even to this very day :/
you might be interested in looking up some old literature that predates psy ops ... Look up 2 books and study them well 1) Gustov Le Bon's "The Crowd" & Walter Lippmann's "Propaganda" While you are at it you might want to also look into Edward Barney's work with "engineering" social trends EG spreading ideas and concepts through the use of social contagion. these works literally make George Orwells 1984 look like child's play ...
In order to maintain power, the ruling class needs to provide bread and circuses to the peasantry. There's plenty of circuses today with sports, reality tv, etc., but they've left out the bread! They seriously need to get their act together or they could lose everything.
The problem is that the people won't do anything until there's no other options. Look around the world, with all the revolutions going on---they didn't happen when people were well tended and happy; it happened when corruption got so ridiculously out of hand it halted basic infrastructure, when jobs became non-existent and unemployment became unavoidable, and when crime and disease became unmitigated - basically, when things went completely to shit.
Sadly I see the same thing around the corner for us in America; we won't fix the problem before everything falls apart - we'll fix it because everything fell apart.
Which is actually my biggest concern, because if that's the case, and the bare minimum is met, nobody will rise up, and there will be no limit to their power. We could literally be looking at the next Nazi / Soviet / Fascist regime; possibly another World War.
The three reasons that Robert Reich enumerated, as to why there is not more resistance from the population at the outright theft of their wealth, is spot on. However, I would suggest three more reasons as to why there is not more dissent:
1. Americans are more distracted than ever before by trivial preoccupations (i.e. Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, reality tv, celebrity culture and sports)
2. While we are producing more college educated people, the focus of their education, and the education of high school kids, is more myopic - concentrating mostly on just the skills necessary to get a decent paying job. In the mad rush to make students more marketable, history, civics, and the social sciences - all subjects which raise consciousness, are being jettisoned, which produces a population of apathetic and ignorant people.
3. People, due to having an impoverished understanding of the world, as stated in point #2, have been duped by the LIE that less government regulation and taxation of the rich and corporate America will FREE the rich to produce greater prosperity for all Americans. Hence, this lulls the working class to not only be complacent, but in many cases to actively work against their own best interests.
Interesting and true. I would add to your #1 simply that we are more busy and tired as a culture. The rat race has one half of our brains occupied and entertainment and tech has the other.
Revolution? Meh, maybe I'll look into it next week.... if I get some time. Hey, do you know when Game of Thrones starts back up?
As long as idiots lead the misled into protesting against buildings, sidewalks, lampposts, and courthouse lawns, instead of protesting directly against who's profiting off the status quo, nothing changes. Nothing. Why would it?
Some might say the Ultra-Orthodox Jews of israel had it right in protesting against being drafted into Zionist terrorist creation machine. I think they blocked freeways. Brilliant. But eh, they were led by people who wanted real change. Actual, you know, C H A N G E .
The main reason is because the United States is ideologically frozen. You can't talk about policy without talking about ideology. And the problem with ideology is that there is a tendency to see it in absolutes. If you support a leftist policy, you are akin to Stalin. If you support a right-wing policy you are a libertarian plutocrat. There's no room for the actual functional middle in American politics anymore. Even though supporting education reform or healthcare reform in no way amounts to Totalitarian Communism, it's just how it is perceived. And the big disadvantage the left has in terms of economic policy making is that their ideological "symbol", even if it doesn't at represent actually liberal and progressive ideals, was the Soviet Union. That symbolic defeat still plagues the confidence of the left to this day.
The labor strikes of the early 20th century had nothing to do with ideology. Labor Unions were formed in response to low wages and unfair working conditions for coal miners. This was a common issue nationwide which caused various labor wars between coal miners and the coal mining companies all across the nation. Since then laws have been passed and working conditions have improved, but America still experiences the occasional armed coal strike as well as several other violent strikes in other occupations, but chances are you will not see another nationwide culmination of labor strikes in a single occupation because there is not a nationwide network of system abuse, but Americans have never stopped revolting.
the main reason people are not doing anything about income inequality is because the majority of people care more about justin bieber and kim kardashians new undies even if their elected representatives are selling their future down a river
The class of drugs that Levitra, Viagra, Stendra, and Cialis belong to are called PDE5 inhibitors. They work by relaxing tight blood vessels, allowing more blood to surge into the penis and cause an erection, says Gregory Bales, M.D., an associate professor of urology at the University of Chicago.
The little pills do the trick for more than two-thirds of men with Viagra protects the heart (ED). They also work for guys who simply need them for a short time to get their “confidence back,” says Michael Eisenberg, M.D., director of male reproductive medicine and surgery at Stanford University.