HomeНовости и политикаRelated VideosMore From: The Quint

Justice Must Not Only be Done, But Must Also Appear to Have Been Done: Justice Chelameswar

1993 ratings | 83235 views
Is the CJI keeping other members of the Collegium in the dark? Why did the four senior SC judges hold that press conference in January? Should the CJI be impeached? Justice Chelameswar answers Karan Thapar’s questions Video: The Quint
Html code for embedding videos on your blog
Text Comments (232)
ABID HUSSAIN (5 hours ago)
When decorated judges like justice chalameshwar who is known for his integrity come out in the open n speak about pitfalls in our judiciary n over enthusiastic government interference,thn it can't be anything but true..
nikitha bakshi (10 days ago)
Now even supreme court is sold. Thanks to modi ji.
KV Santhosh (15 days ago)
Most corrupted Congress judge.neither have wisdom nor knowledge.
Turtle Mind (18 days ago)
Karan thapar..!😠 My foot who made him host? Pathetic looser. Totally biased intellectual mafia.
Srinivasan Salem (18 days ago)
Long live judiciary.
Jnaneshwar Konanur (20 days ago)
These judges finally got publicity
Sachin Singh (22 days ago)
Cristians + Muslims eat beef -------- they always oppose Hindu
Raja King (23 days ago)
Today he is resigns.....supreme COURT doesn't work properly...india don't more to be democracy.....country
Sreerag Suresh (27 days ago)
Legend
Pragya Cute (1 month ago)
His personality says everything , honest judge .
Jibu Thomas (1 month ago)
Thank you. Quint..you are the one... maintain unbiased...whoever is in power
Arup Chand (1 month ago)
(S)quinting by the (S)quint
praveen p (2 months ago)
Judges have always kept themselves away from public interactions & debates. Othe than the above judge it has been very rare that judges have given interviews to media while they are still serving. This is to ensure their non bias towards everone. A supreme court judge speaking to media and that too giving interview to a highly biased joirnalist raises question marks on the intentions of this esteemed judge
Abhinav T (2 months ago)
He should have been the CJI... 😟
Keshav Jha (2 months ago)
Har har modi...Jai sri ram...
kunal Moharana (2 months ago)
#communist slave
sugeeth sugeeth (2 months ago)
We are sorry honourable justice chalameshwar sir , we the people who voted those thugs to power and all this is happening because of that big mistake of us. That's it the only last hope was judiciary and now that too is in danger . This country is not for good and honest people .
Ananth Pamarthi (2 months ago)
He is communist supporter
MOHD AZMAT (2 months ago)
beta you are talking to a judge...
Garugu Suresh Reddy (2 months ago)
Did you asked him about “Not before me” ? They are useing it to escape from few cases to deliver through them? If any judge purchased corporate company’s shares and at the time of their case hearing , last minute disclosed of the same and askeing to shift case to another judge ,..saving / favering corporate houses?
SD7 (2 months ago)
What a candid interview. I really appreciate his straightforwardness.
Vaibhav Srivastava (2 months ago)
I still can't believe the fact that interviewer is one of the great journalist of India.
Abraham (2 months ago)
Chelameswar is a legend
Sunil Ghorpade (2 months ago)
In current situation / in Modi regime and under such circumstances , i think next CJI certainly not Justice Gogoi , though he is Senior most and meritorious
Surendra Khanna (2 months ago)
Theatrics nonsense by Congress stooges.
guru ramphul (2 months ago)
u chamar put your hand on your heart and claim impartiality , you meet left leaders in public, that very day u should have been sacked, qas you brought politics in your being a judge, you chamar, hang yourself what you and the others pidi followe have brought judiciary to, a dog war, hang yourself, do u think i will belive in any of your judgement to be impartial as from now on or your pidi followers, do you want me to just laugh at your face of being impartial, pl help yourself and india with all you and your pidis resign
KIRAN KULKARNI (2 months ago)
HE IS BIG ""CRY BABY""... HE WANTED TO GIVE A CONFLICTING DECISIONS BASED ON HIS COMI AGENDA, IN BIG CASES, HE COULD NOT ... NOW HE IS CRYING HERE... ALL 4 JUDGES HAVE EXPOSED THEMSELVES ... AND THEIR LOYALITIES... FOR THE FIRAT TIME I AM FEELING EVEN JUDGEMENTS CAN VARY ON PERSONAL IDEOLOGIES
landrovar (2 months ago)
wow! such a wise and talented man we have in Judiciary.Thats why we trust our judiciary.He deserved to be the CJI
Wrik Sen (2 months ago)
Straight and to the point, Justice Chelameshwar.. he knows what he is doing, and doing so in such a way, that it hits the right notes wit the right people.. there will always be a bunch of clowns questioning Chelameshwar's role or whom he met, but the word is clear about his stance and the problems which exist in the judiciary today..
Mohammed Tajuddin (2 months ago)
Its time people of india grow some brains and not vote goondas and rascals to high power, surely all institutions will get affected.
Uday Prabhakar (2 months ago)
The opposition feel and suspect the present CJI is BJP agent.
Nirmal Raj (2 months ago)
Judges must refrain from interacting with public outside court. They need to find a remedy within their system to clean up the mess,and avoid washing dirty linen in public.
Philip Roji (2 months ago)
i hope this man is very honest
devi prasad (2 months ago)
Jai Hind...we have complete faith in Modiji....
akky kumar (2 months ago)
I am living in a country where chief judges are worried about judiciary and it's behaviour , is that good sign or bad ?
Ajinkya Pawar (2 months ago)
His thought process is crystal clear. Respect to institution of justice.
Rahul f (2 months ago)
Not many knows he had done great service to the country by by judgement on freedom of speech, I'm instant fan of his wisdom... Great men like him are needed, salute🙏🙏🙏
naresh bandari (2 months ago)
can he talk to republic
Srinivasan Salem (2 months ago)
Judiciary & press media are pillars of democracy.
Srinivasan Salem (2 months ago)
Long live judiciary.
balwinder singH (2 months ago)
Justice Chelameswar is tHe reason wHi i believe in constitution
Sajadur Chowdhury (2 months ago)
Ur the best sir
iemon (2 months ago)
Karan Thapar makes me cringe so hard!
anuj gupta (2 months ago)
this judge has sold his soul & his noble profession of law to Congress...shameful..puppet of Congress ...why suddenly just before 2019 election all these games being played..
SWAMI SHANKAR DYAL (2 months ago)
Karan Thappar stinks..and the other out classed KT..
rajesh kumar verma (2 months ago)
जज साहब बाहर निकलिए ओर पूरा पूरा सच 2 टूक जनता के सामने रख दिजीये।
madu sekhar (2 months ago)
He is corrupted judge. He has no ethiks. He is most corrupted judge. He is very biased . He is doing caste poltics
Deepak Wagle (2 months ago)
Justice Chelameshwar needs self introspection. When he points a finger to CJI ( thinking as if CJI is separate from rest) he feels confident that three fingers (three senior Judges) are pointing towards him to reinforce his self motive or self purpose. But Justice Chelameshwar probably does not know that the thumb is pointing upward towards HIM the almighty. I am sure that the Almighty would always give "SadBudhdhi" and not "Sadistic Budhdhi" . The whole Nation is in pain towards this Justice Vs Justice Drama except pro Rahul-Sonia Corrupt Congress (Pro Man Mohan Singh Congress surely not). Hope after his self introspection Justice Chelameshwar would come clean on the fact that he is not a "Chela" of any vested interest and would not tarnish Judiciary and National image / status within India and also internationally. I wonder if Chelameshwar can discuss his grievance with the President of India to come up with the solution towards a mechanism to resolve such issues internally. I would advise Justice Chelameshwar to approach Sadguru to get spiritual guidance. Just like "Justice Must not Only be Done, But Must Also Appear to Have Been Done" it can also be said that " Injustice Must not be Done and Must not appear to have been Done" In this matter while it can be assumed that Justice Chelameshwar is seeking Justice for the internal administration of Judiciary but certainly he is appearing to give injustice to India in respect of Its Image. Pakistan and some anti Indian international forces must be happy about it. Rahu-Sonia Congress axis not excluded.
Satyamev Jayate (2 months ago)
This fellow must be thrown away immediately out of the court.
Anil Kumar (2 months ago)
he is absolutely right
TheSrij (2 months ago)
He is flying baloons. His grouse is that one of his judgement was overturned by CJI. Useless fellows. Breaking India forces.
Ladi Singh (2 months ago)
This man gone mad and giving political speech.he should resign if he wanna join politics
Priya Prayog (2 months ago)
Justice chalmeshwar is far better than Modi, justice chalmeshwar in his limits, whatever he could do, he is doing it, respected you sir.
Ramesh Chandra Joshi (2 months ago)
थापर जी को नमस्कार आप द्वारा लिए गए इन्टरव्यू बहुत ही प्रभावी एवं भविष्य के लिए भी अच्छे पथ प्रदर्शक लगते है ।अच्छा हो अगर हमे इनका हिंदी अनुवाद मिल जाए । धन्यवाद ।
Surya Teja (2 months ago)
OMG!!! Thanks Quint for this video.
Krish M (2 months ago)
Basic principle of justice is What you see and hear is not correct ....detail investigation without bias is the correct Where is the question of appearing to be correct ....fool ......how he raised to SC level I am wondering
Samir Z (2 months ago)
Left, right and center there is chaos in the country since BJP has come. God save our nation.
guru ramphul (2 months ago)
you pidi man who claims to be a judge , your should be hanged in public for your comments as your pidi affilation speaks
Knight Owl (2 months ago)
If a Judge doesn't believe Judges working with him, how come a nation trust Judiciary system?
Vijay Rajeswar Rao Parsa (2 months ago)
I regret to say sorry for the behavior of Four Judges
न्याय के देवता my lord....
Aditya Shukla (3 months ago)
Current CJI and Justice Chelameshwar were appointed on same day to Supreme court... So that Justice Chelameshwar should not become CJI because of less experience in High Court...
Manjeet Singh (3 months ago)
CJI and modi government are not working according to the constitutional system.....they do what they want,....if this type of things are happenng in apex court then REALLY our DEMOCRACY AND CONSTITUTION ARE IN DANGER.......
dharma ch (3 months ago)
We respect judiciary sir. I hate bjp because it try to collapse judiciary..
Anurag Sinha (3 months ago)
This guy is a sold out leftist bootlicker.. either say it or shut the fuck up don't play hide and seek.
Dilip Save (3 months ago)
Chelmeshwar is playing politics at the hands of congress. In the process, he has done immense damage to the institution of Supreme Court.
Mohd Ali (3 months ago)
He is nice justice
Bhishm Kapoor (3 months ago)
Many people in the audience and in the comments section seem too eager to clap... So much so that even if Chelameshwar pouts or farts, they would still clap with ecstasy!!
Bhishm Kapoor (3 months ago)
Bhakts of Zakir Naik are also the Bhakts of this congress stooge!
CraPure (3 months ago)
Only person who fucked thapar asshole very hard
PRATIK CHANNAWAR (3 months ago)
it was great to listen your conversation who are at top of the two institutions of our democracy
narendra shukla (3 months ago)
Very erudite Judge,a man of simplicity and integrity
mark vaz (3 months ago)
He should have been the CJI but lost marginally with timing of his oath taking
Suriya Uploads (3 months ago)
Chors
Edmund (3 months ago)
Yes Karan, Justice Chelameshwar was kept out of the loop, because you don't want honest officials like him in who are a nuisance to a fantastically corrupt system where the CJI is a stooge on the payroll of Modi.
Mohamed Mueen (3 months ago)
This govt is sabotaging the intellect of our country.
Victor Reynolds (2 months ago)
Mohamed Mueen, Mohamed wss your greatest intellectual
m a gulfam (3 months ago)
Courageous man. Thanks for your time
Ram Gupta (3 months ago)
Sure he is a genius and blah blah blah but politicizing judiciary coming out on TV debates and that too with known journalist brothel born parasites clearly indicates your attentions judge. You can fool some people with your verbal command but not all of them and we have seen your rage when you bring your fight out in public with three other idiots like public has chosen you and made you a judge. I can surly see this pattern out against current Government and especially against PM Modi. These bastards who call themselves fourth pillar of democracy are ruining it for genuine journalists but it looks like queen bee is more stronger than Modi and with left which is unemployed right now, your tantrums and pimps and Presstitutes combined together could be deadly for Modi. And common man in this country who want development and equality will have to wake up and not to fall in this fake emotional dramas and do bring back him as PM again.
Mehul Jain (15 days ago)
Ram Gupta sir, you think he woke up one day and decided to go to media. Read his letter. It has been going on for a very long time.
Amitabh Shukla (2 months ago)
Ram Gupta sir, with due respect to your age, i don't want to argue with anyone who reacts after sitting at home and listening to paid media.. you didn't apply your mind and matter is hence over..
Ram Gupta (2 months ago)
Amitabh Shukla instead of giving sermons why not give your input about the issue in favour or against & what should be done I might be less qualified and aged but you are in a responsible position in Government Job as you said and why calling any one names ? Doesn’t it shows your bias and frustration . All I’m asking is Don’t get personal or their will be no difference between a genuine blogger and a troll. I hope you to get well soon
Saqib Saleem (2 months ago)
Ram Gupta, my sincere rebuttal of your insolence, * Judges are not chosen by the people. Read the whole procedure in the Constitution articles read with supreme Court judgments. * Separation of powers has to stay in a working democracy, of which judicial review is an essential ingredient. So all government actions, be they by NDA or UPA, has to be subjected to this feature. (Refer to your Modi argument) * Development is the most misunderstood concept in india, pls read anti-development thesis and Amartya sen concept of development, M sure all yours misconceptions will collapse by giving an objective reading to it. (Refer to your development argument). All else you said is crap.
Amitabh Shukla (2 months ago)
Ram Gupta i do have manners and i hold a responsible post in the government.. However, i am highly frustrated by the blindness and foolishness of Indians like you bcz of whom our whole nation, we all and our future all are getting jeopardized day by day apace..and with all due respect, age doesn't automatically entitle you for respect.. your wisdom does which unfortunately you don't seemingly have..broaden your horizons
md zameer uddin (3 months ago)
Great...
Garima Singh (3 months ago)
Obviously the govt is not fond of appointing honest judges like you! Ya the current CJI is a good puppet to ruin the autonomy of judiciary as well as our faith on it !
the Rajat (3 months ago)
What's happening in this country??
All in one (3 months ago)
Great journalist with honest judiciary person
AHMAD ALI (3 months ago)
I’m damn sure, if sankhis will get one more chance to rule, India will face one more division.. A north based Hindustan and a south based Republic of India... India is dying, these morons are playing with our life, culture and values...
siddharth wadgavkar (3 months ago)
Why Modi ji please stop polluting to judiciary system. U brought media now u wanted to buy judiciary... Please stop.
Pragya Cute (1 month ago)
siddharth wadgavkar he is polluting the nation as well
rohit agrawal (3 months ago)
Cji of india mr dipak mishra is a bjp man .
Mohammed boss (3 months ago)
IT CELL IS active to make anti national for this judge I am proud of you sir you come public told what is happening in our supreme court
Dhairysheel Ghatge (3 months ago)
The occurrences of certain events in respect of the judiciary which indicates that the govt is unduly interfering with the functioning of the judiciary, it is the duty of the people to dislodge such govt.
Harsh Vardhan (3 months ago)
Seriously hypocrisy at its worst.Do we have this precedence to hold a press conference??This judge and many others like him would definitely ruin the institution of which they are pretending to uphold the integrity.Good going guys, let us see what will happen when Mr Gogoi will take charge and he will be demeaned by some section of media and judiciary.Let this precedence prevail and I will see how these liberal champions will support the dissent then.
bhaskar thakur (3 months ago)
This what we all need to know what is happening in our country no media so called "godi media" reports such incidents on television bcs they did not want us to be aware of such reports makes us away from such reports nd puzzled in Hindu Muslim topics...due to this we all are facing today a very serious problem of communal rights , unemployment ,corruption, economy falling down gradually, in hunger index today India is 100th position from 110 countries which was below Pakistan #shame on government
Ayush soni (3 months ago)
Lots of Congi Slaves here
Lone Wolf (3 months ago)
He must have secured it using sc/st quota.
Zeeshan Siddique (3 months ago)
What an intellectual personality. I will add he is an outstanding judge
kuldeep pandita (3 months ago)
Yeh toh wohi chutiya hai na Jo D Raja se mila tha
John Medhinshalva (2 months ago)
I can say he is best justice in India
Pablo Escobar (3 months ago)
Bring judiciary under RTI.
voice of India (3 months ago)
It's a dangerous trend judges are setting! Was there no political interference at all in SUPREME COURT ever before? Or was it convenient for few ppl then rather than if it's exists, now? Any form of interference at any time (present or past) is unwelcome. I strongly feel judiciary must be more responsible and sort out issues internally rather than playing for the gallery. Is there a beneficiary of this kinda act? If so, who?
NDN (3 months ago)
27 chutiye Bhakt dislike it..
NDN (2 months ago)
Lone Wolf Wo Terra dada hai re beta
Lone Wolf (3 months ago)
Tere baap hai bhakt. 27 vhakt
mithun murali (3 months ago)
One of the most self assured men ever.... Owned Mr Thapar through out the interview...
mithun murali (3 months ago)
that is what is meant by "owned Mr Thapar"...he answered all his provocative questions with the prudence and eloquence of a seasoned jurist
Xyz Abc (3 months ago)
mithun murali there was nothing to be owned.. He answered questions bravely, given the ruling cowards in executive
shreyash Chaudhari (3 months ago)
Looks like... first time the Judge is being Accused by Someone...😂😂
Nirmal Raj (2 months ago)
shreyash Chaudhari yes it's a serious situation for Indian judiciary. But remedy must come from within and not from the public or media.
GRAY WOLF (3 months ago)
Be it the radical left or the right everyone is sitting in someone's pocket.and its hard to digest that he is not without any agenda.

Would you like to comment?

Join YouTube for a free account, or sign in if you are already a member.